Jack Black and the San Fransisco Shock

Burglar Jack Black was reading by candlelight in his dank dark cell in the early morning of April 18, 1906, when he felt the earth shake. He’d been two years in San Francisco’s Broadway county jail awaiting a hearing on appeal. He woke up his cellmate and then came another shock. By now the whole block was awake and guards were running this way and that, jailbirds were squawking. At the third shock Jack realized for sure that something serious was afoot. He was kind of excited; here was a change in routine that might break to his advantage.

The old Broadway jail in North Beach, built at the time of the forty-niners half a century ago, was a two-story structure and including a basement with a solid stone foundation so it didn’t much rock during the earthquake and it wasn’t destroyed in the rampant fires that followed either like so many buildings in the same neighborhood. (Today San Francisco’s Beat Museum stands in the exact location of this former county jail.) The rats knew a good thing when they found it; Jack said they practically took over the jail every night, coming up through the floors of cells from the sewers running below. Unlike the rats, though, the prisoners must’ve felt trapped inside while structures collapsed all around them; they could see ruination just across the street from their absurdly sturdy structure. Jack and his cellmate crouched under the arch of their cell door and listened to the rising panic. He noted an old-timer guard holding up his hands, shouting, “’Tis the curse of an angry god on a wicked city!” As ever Black is apt in delineating the philosophical correspondences between captives and their captors in close quarters.

In the event, more and more prisoners were brought into the jail while the inmates wondered what if anything would be done with them. A man who said he was a saloonkeeper was put into Jack’s cell, half hysterical. “Everything I have in the world is gone!” he said to Jack, and then he told the story of how he’d tried to get into his saloon and retrieve money from his safe but was arrested in the process. “The soldiers wouldn’t let me.” Other men were bayoneted or shot for the same offense. (It was three weeks before this man got his liberty, Jack reported.)

While the jail became crowded with suspect detainees and even child prisoners—mere freewheeling hooligans remanded by militia or overeager citizen lawmen who’d commandeered a weapon and played at enforcer—and as the city continued to burn the convicts hoped like hell the fire would approach close enough that their guards would have no choice but to let them all go.

*

The Frisco earthquake and its harrowing aftermath was the story of the year. Numerous histories and reportage were issued from that day to this—though none that I have read cared to make any mention of the condition and circumstances of the city’s incarcerated during the days-long disaster, mismanaged in so many respects in any case. Thanks to Black’s singular account (published some eight years later in the San Francisco Bulletin as part of a longer series of sketches of his incarceration), we know the authorities’ hold on prisoners amidst the crisis remained powerfully in place certainly as seen in the same aggressive light as the city’s chief military officer’s controversial order to arrest and detain, when not shooting to kill, any and all lawbreakers under any circumstance (this kill order was in fact officially imposed and martial law made publicly known within hours of the morning tremors, illegally so, it turned out). In fact, those put in positions of authority within the emergency—or those who’d taken authority upon themselves in the chaos—succeeded in this mission above all expectation. While the city burned and fell fully a sixth of the victims of the catastrophe (that is, some 500 victims) had been summarily executed by a myriad of law and order compliance and enforcement. Citizens being gunned down by overzealous soldiers in front of their homes, having attempted to enter again for any reason, for example, was not at all uncommon. Nor were haphazard but murderous vigilance committees, on the prowl under bellicose, panic-driven, self-made rule of law. For Jack Black and the other furtives and outcasts it was an overripe if predictable worst-case scenario when John Citizen has homemade law at his trigger finger.

*

Jack London, who was there, reported: “San Francisco is gone … wiped out… . The factories and warehouses, the great stores and newspaper buildings, the hotels and the palaces of the nabobs, are all gone.” Etc. But it is a tired report of tired yet still smoking facts both in its weary tone and in its clichéd magazine-ready presentation. The author plainly didn’t want to be there but he was on the job for populist Collier’s magazine, he badly needed the bread. (And in fact he was getting paid per word, which explains to my mind the needlessly repeated empty talk throughout his report.) He saw a lot of flames, a lot of crushed buildings, a darkening sky, plenty of folks with trunks dragging their last worldly belongings through the angry streets. Okay but. He didn’t see much else besides these headlines, or care to, it seems: none of the looting and shooting, apparently, that other better reporters were soon to provide. Why didn’t he? London closes saying the bankers and nabobs by the third day are already planning the new city. Sure they were, rubbing their hands hotly, too, undoubtedly, soon as their hired “special police force” coppers and well-armed federal soldiers, bayonets up, got rid of the rest of the useless upon these city elders’ not so silent orders. C’mon, Jack, where’s your fiery socialist finger pointing the profiteers of crisis. London had reported, memorably, that strangely enough “it was a quiet night.” Yet wherefor the many marauders justifying the immediate call for martial law? One would have hoped his reportage had made that salient point as well, but no, not this time.

Just two years prior London had created, in his exceptional novel The Sea-Wolf, one of the most complex antagonists in all of modern lit, the sea captain Wolf Larsen, a memorably unvexed individual who, it seems to me, might’ve relished the burn and found a way to coattail and corral not only the riffraff but the undisguised opportunists of chaos as well. In point of fact the city of San Francisco at the turn of the nineteenth century was one of the most notoriously corrupt cities in the nation, where factions of corruptors warred for public monies, making their own rules along the way, despite repeated calls for reform by lone wolves such as newspaper editor Fremont Older (Jack Black’s future boss and friend). Many of the city’s buildings constructed in the late nineteenth century, for instance, were so poorly built that they easily crumbled after the first shock and/or succumbed to the widespread fires in the quake’s aftermath, exposing in the rubble the graft of their creation. This fact was mostly successfully covered up when the reconstruction began for those same political malefactors would bid again for the reckless building up of their city, and in time too for a world’s fair exposition proving it less than a decade later. Such is the forward march of civilization, historically speaking, unrestrained by the selective memory of its citizens.

*

In 1923 Lon Chaney starred in a movie whose climax was the 1906 San
Francisco earthquake, titled The Shock (“shock” as a descriptive noun for this mother of all quakes was in all too common use in the period and well afterward), in which he portrayed a career criminal who has to decide either to remain in the life or to change his ways before the roof and much else collapses on his world. The quake plainly symbolizes the rupture in the life of the character, just as it had in fact for Jack Black, in lockup awaiting his fate at the time of the storied catastrophe some two decades earlier.

Jack Black and Lon Chaney were, oddly enough, lookalikes, the actor’s torment showing more than just in the eyes (à la JB’s aspect), of course, certainly in this sentimental crime picture set in the period just prior to the great earthquake, much of it in criminal underground headquarters in the bay city’s Chinatown, one of Jack’s own favorite districts in the city. The Shock features plenty of programmatic corn but such is the melodrama that the tormented crippled burglar and button man Chaney is cured rather than further injured in the climactic shock. (Some footage of the dramatic aftermath of the actual quake was used in the feature.) In point of fact there were not very many happy endings for the good people in the wake of the real-life Frisco shock.

*

When Sailor Jack London, road kid, was stealing the hats off Chinamen, Jack Black was already a member in good standing of the yegg fraternity of Johnsons, and good people could vouch for him from Frisco to Pocatello to Denver. By the mid-aughts—each having traveled more than most; one couldn’t stop talking about it and the other wouldn’t talk at all—Jack London was a bestselling author and Jack Black was an accomplished outlaw.

In his anecdotal autobiographical The Road London writes of his youthful experimental hoboing and also, in a couple of short “facetious” chapters, of his brief but telling turn in lockup, arrested for vagrancy and sentenced to a measly thirty days in the pen despite his pseudo-intellectual protests in court to the contrary. (In common with Jack Black the judge in London’s case also scoffed at such brazenly broadcasted hubris, however intelligently explanatory.) What’s surprising I suppose to the general reader of London as polemicist of injustice is how young Jack soon enough sided with the guards’ authority over his weaker-minded inmates. Sure he outwitted the prison guards and the other trustees, too, but looking out for himself, and no professional outlaw, he wangled his way out from inside with (likely) no more than a few bruises to his wits. It wouldn’t be till much later—many working lives and bestselling books later—that he wrote one of the most original novels on prison life of his or any time, titled The Star Rover, about a prisoner who in order to beat the brutal system withdraws from waking reality into dreams and past lives, thwarting his keepers by surviving the punishing straitjacket. That’s a whole nother London chapter, though, when he’d become prematurely aged and was thinking otherworldly.

Sailor Jack had seemingly settled down to authoring giant bestselling adventure novels but professional burglar and road bum Black found himself once more in stir, this time in the San Francisco county jail, which is where he was in April 1906 when the big quake struck the city and smashed its capital dreams.

*

Jack and the other inmates with long sentences hanging over them who’d been praying that the raging fires would result in their being set free were cruelly disappointed. In a dubious decision regarding the distribution of manpower in a crisis, men better employed in helping homeless victims of the quake or in disaster rescue and firefighting were sent to the jails in many multiples. Jack says three lines of guards—militia, marines, and sheriff’s deputies—were ordered to escort fewer than one hundred prisoners to a safe haven in order that none may flee the transfer nor have any chance of escape in new quarters. One prison guard left his home and family in peril in order to see to it that none of his charges got away. The prisoners despised him for it. Very late on the night of the shock, when at last the jailors took their prisoners into the streets outside, force marched in shackles and cuffs, it was near bright as day. “We found ourselves in a glare of light,” Jack later wrote. “Kearny street was on fire. Chinatown was burning. The sky was red.”

The prisoners were herded aboard a government tug and made for the state pen at San Quentin up the coast. When they arrived a lawyer in the prisoners’ ranks (he was inside for bigamy, Jack said) made a convincing argument that they couldn’t be legally transferred to the state prison and after some arguing and waiting around they shoved off for Alcatraz instead, where the prisoners stayed put for three days until it was decided what to do with them. Jack says they used up and traded their store of hop with the resident population and watched the city burn all day and all night. Finally a group of the more serious cons, including Black who faced a twenty-five-year sentence for highway robbery, were taken to the Oakland city prison where they immediately made plans to escape. That came to naught as there were just too many soldiers and other deputized guards on duty during the long emergency.

Meantime San Francisco’s hall of justice burned to the ground, including all of the city’s court records. Jack at first thought this would get him some leverage but when the state’s legislature met soon enough in the wake of the catastrophe it was decided that all pending appeals would remain pending under emergency laws providing relief for the courts but, not surprisingly, none for prisoners. Although the bedrock-built Broadway jail had escaped destruction the immediate area was in ruins so Jack was among those transferred to another city jail situated in a less fraught section of the city and he settled down to wait. “It is the one hope of a prisoner in as desperate a situation as we were,” he said, “to wait,” hoping, that is, for a chance that something, anything might turn up. But Jack Black was wise to the ways of authority, and he was impassive, philosophical. He was not easily shocked. He had chosen the life. “I waited six years in that cell in the Ingleside jail.”

by Donald Kennison

Previous
Previous

‘Text Me You Haven’t Died’ - My Sister was the 166th Doctor to Be Murdered in Gaza

Next
Next

Broadly Grinning Fascism